• AOL
  • My AOL
  • Mail
  • Make BlackVoices My HomePage
  • ENTERTAINMENT NEWS
  • MOVIES
  • TELEVISION
  • MUSIC
  • RADIO
  • GAMES
  • BLACK VOICES
  • TMZ
Black Voices
Black Voices
Web
SEARCH Search The Web Magnify Glass
x
  • Main
  • News
  • Entertainment
  • Life & Style
  • Olympics
  • Work & Money
  • Blogs
  • Boards
  • Videos
  • Back 2 School
Send Feedback
BV BLOGS
  • Main
  • AIDS: 25 Years and Counting
  • Black Spin
  • BV Buzz
  • Casually Obsessed
  • Entertainment Newswire
  • Hair Apparent
  • It's All Reel
  • Money Talks
  • More Than Words
  • Style Spotter
Blog Categories
  • Life and Style
  • News
  • Entertainment
  • Sports
RESOURCESsquare
  • Contact Us
  • Corrections
  • Problems
  • RSS Feeds
  • Send Us Tips
BLOG ROLLsquare
  • (Red)
  • Afrobella
  • AIDS Combat Zone
  • All About Race
  • AMBERmag.com Fashion & Beauty
  • Anderson@Large Political Blog
  • Baller Status
  • Black Web 2.0
  • Bossip
  • Brown Sista
  • Canada's HipHossip
  • Clay Cane
  • Clutch
  • Cocoa Lounge
  • Concrete Loop
  • Crunk Disorderly
  • Drew Reports
  • Funky Brown Chick Humor
  • I Love Black Movies
  • Jack and Jill Politics
  • Janet Charlton's Hollywood
  • JuicyScoop
  • Love B. Scott
  • Molifeney
  • Nah Right
  • NPR News & Notes Blog
  • Perez Hilton
  • Political Machine Elections Blog
  • Politics in Color
  • Pop Culture Junkie
  • Popeater AOL Music
  • Queersighted
  • Real Talk NY
  • Rhymes with Snitch
  • Sandra Varner's Talk 2 SV
  • Seventh Square
  • Smoking Section
  • Soul Bounce Music
  • Spinner
  • Stereo Hyped
  • Strictly Fabulous Style
  • StyleList AOL Style
  • That Grape Juice
  • The Black Informant
  • The People's News
  • The Root
  • TMZ
  • Today's Drum
  • VisualAIDS
  • Wallet Pop
  • Young, Black & Fabulous

Obama Wasn't Marching in Memphis - Does it Matter?

Posted Apr 7th 2008 9:00AM by Faye Anderson
Filed under: BlackSpin, Elections, Barack Obama, Martin Luther King Jr.

I spent most of last week in Memphis, where I paid tribute to Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. on the 40th anniversary of his assassination. Many traveled from across the country, including John McCain who apologized for opposing the King Holiday bill.

Hillary Clinton was in Memphis to pay her respects and speak before the Church of God in Christ Pan African Leadership Summit at Mason Temple. She also took a tour of the National Civil Rights Museum.



Did he make his move too soon?

Barack Obama was conspicuous by his absence. Frankly, I'm bothered that Obama didn't bother to show up. Dr. King paid the ultimate sacrifice so that African Americans could get to the "mountaintop" but Obama could not sacrifice a few hours of campaigning.

Instead, he was "spreading the message" in Indiana, which holds its primary on May 6. He phoned it in, saying:
I spoke at Dr. King's church on his birthday. I was with the King family then. I obviously gave a fairly fulsome speech on the state of race relations just two weeks ago. And I think it's important to spread the message that Dr. King's work is unfinished in places like Indiana and North Dakota.
Obama's absence speaks volumes about 'the state of race relations." Shelby Steele, a senior fellow at the Hoover Institution and author of "A Bound Man: Why We Are Excited About Barack Obama and Why He Can't Win," told the Los Angeles Times:
Obama is going back to the larger strategy he used up until Rev. Wright, which is to downplay race.

He knows if there is this backdrop of black protest and anger, the white working-class voters he is trying to pull his way are going to peel away. His whole strategy is to relieve the anxiety by saying he is not interested in race, that he is transcending race.
Good luck with that. A recent New York Times poll found:
The survey suggests that Mr. Obama, Democrat of Illinois, may have been at something of a peak in February, propelled by a string of primary and caucus victories over Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton of New York, and that perceptions of him are settling down.

Mr. Obama's favorable rating among Democratic primary voters has dropped seven percentage points, to 62 percent, since the last Times/CBS News survey, in late February. While that figure is by any measure high, the decline came in a month during which he endured withering attacks from Mrs. Clinton and responded to reports that his former pastor had made politically inflammatory statements from his church's pulpit in Chicago.
African Americans remain Obama's most loyal supporters. Blacks gave Obama a pass on skipping Tavis Smiley's annual conference. But he should not be given a free ride. A point underscored by Obama supporter, Cornel West:
I want to say that I'm deeply disappointed that my dear brother Barack Obama decided not to go pay tribute and lay his wreath for the great Martin Luther King, Jr. That brother Martin's profound love and deep sacrifice for black people, America and humanity is in no way reducible to political calculations, even for the campaign for presidency. That Martin Luther King Jr.'s deep commitment to unarmed truth and unconditional love can in no way be subject to strategies for access to political power. Hence, I have a very deep disagreement with my dear brother, Barack Obama -- in this case, commitment to truth is in tension with the quest for power.
Memphis is "Blues City." Every blues lover knows you "never make your move too soon." If Obama doesn't stand with black folks as we honor an American icon, who's to say he'll stand up for black Americans if he gets to the Oval Office?
  • Permalink
  • Email this
  • Share
  • Comments [484]

Reader Comments

(Page 1)

1. I think we should let the man run his race. The black race has always wanted to hold everyone accountable but ourselves. It is wonderful that you were there; however, it doesn't make you more beneficia to the black community because of your attendance. What black people need is leaders who will work for them when the cameras are not there and when it's not a who's who star studded event of the political elite. I think you are one of the people who would have been criticizing MLK when he was alive because he wasn't following "your" plan. We have to understand there are many different ways to be in support of something and your way doesn't have to be the only way. Al Sharpton said he's more interested in what people do after the event and so are most black people. Articles like this, is why we are not as far along as the hispanics and asians because we always, always, drag down the people who we think have arrived. For some reason, we take great issue with black success in our community. Perhaps it is the house "black" syndrome from slavery. Barack is a leader but we are all leaders and all responsible for forwarding MLK's dream. I don't give him more responsibility than myself just because he's running for president. And please, let's not be fooled by some who did attend.

tired of crazy black people at 9:58AM on Apr 7th 2008

2. Obama did the right thing by not going to Memphis. McCain and Clinton weren't "paying respects;" they were cashing in. They talked about themselves. Obama's tribute was to Dr. King.

Molly Pickett at 10:04AM on Apr 7th 2008

3. Obama did the right thing. We all know who the man is and what he stands for. Let him continue the business of wining this nomination and then the general election. That will be the biggest tribute to Dr. King and what he stood for.

Robert at 10:28AM on Apr 7th 2008

4. Faye Anderson is nothing more than a Hilary Clinton supporter. John McCain and Hilary Clinton went to Memphis to do nothing more than give a politico speech. Keep in mind John McCain like his fellow republicans wouldn't even go before a black audience during the republican primary. Hilary was even down playing King’s importance earlier during the democratic primary.

Johnlee at 10:56AM on Apr 7th 2008

5. Obama spoke at the Church to honor king a few weeks ago and he spent time with the king family. There is no need for him to go to Memphis. People are always looking for something to criticize..leave the man alone and pray that he or Hillary win so that we can get the republicans out of there and back to a state of normalcy.

Earl Henry at 11:03AM on Apr 7th 2008

6. I am glad Obama chose not to go to Memphis. Besides staying away from the travesty of having McCain and Clinton politicizing this tragic memory, the thought of Obama on that balcony scares me to death. Think of how a mentally disturbed person might imagine the headline grabbing infamy of replicating that horrific incident. Let's be grateful for the wisdom of Senator Obama and let's not try to imagine why he did or did not attend.


carol Wandrey at 11:06AM on Apr 7th 2008

7. LET OBAMA RUN FOR PRESIDENT. HE WILL HONOR DR. KING AND HIS DREAM IF HE WIN!! THE OTHER TWO CANDIDATES WERE JUST SURFING FOR VOTES. STOP BEING CRABS IN THE BUCKET. YOU KNOW WHAT THE DEAL IS. THE MEDIA WOULD ONLY SHOW FOOTAGE OF SOME SMALL INSIGNIFICANT HE SAID TAKEN OUT OF CONTEXT AND SPIN IT WITH REV. WRIGHT FOOTAGE. KEEP YOUR EYES ON THE BIGGGER PICTURE

PT at 11:15AM on Apr 7th 2008

8. ONCE AGAIN ANOTHER VERSION OF DOUBLE STANDARDS.YOURE TELLING ME THAT IF SAY OBAMA AND MCAIN WERE IN MEMPHIS AND NOT HILLARY(WHO I DONT SUPPORT)DID NOT SHOW THAT SHE WOULD NOT HAVE BEEN ATTACKED?PLEASE!DOUBT THAT SHE WOULD RECEIVE THESE NICE LIBERAL STATEMENT ON THIS SITE LIKE "HEY ITS NOT THAT IMPORTANT"THEN HOW COME MANY DIGNATARIES SHOWED UP THERE,WHY WAS THERE A MARCH?WHY DID THE OTHER TWO CANDIDATE MAKE SURE THAT THEY WERE THERE AND HAD TO SCHEDULE MONTHS IN ADVANCE?WHY?BECAUSE IT IS IMPORTANT TO SHOW RESPECT THE MLK AND HIS CAUSE!ALSO ILL BET IF THE ANNIVERSARY OF JFK WERE COMING UP OBAMA WOULD BE THERE!WHY?BECAUSE HE NEEDS THE WHITE VOTE AND ALREADY HAS THE BLACK VOTE THAT MAY BE WHY HE WASNT IN MEMPHIS!

LL at 11:46AM on Apr 7th 2008

9. What would you rather have those of us like Barack Obama who fully Respect The Rev Martin Luther King Jr, we did not need to be in Memphis last week to show our support which is shown each and every day or do we give credence to those who objected to the MLK Pubic Holiday and did still feel this way until recently, quite a turn around, but when you want votes?

Rather than the attack on Barack Obama I feel we should question two other figures in this Election Race, did they try to use the memory of The Great Man The Rev Martin Luther King Jr as a PR Vehicle for their own Political interests, that is a more serious question and I have doubts about both of their sincerity!

John B Sheffield at 12:30PM on Apr 7th 2008

10. I support Senator Obama's deecision to stay on his mission and continue campaigning. I was part of a large labor delegation in Memphis for the King holiday celebration, we spend thousands in airfare, hotel, food and entertainment. I went home asking myself wht I needed to go to Memphis to volunteer or th hear the speeches. And my biggest question what did I change by being there? I could have been more effective working with the domestic violence organization I founded in Philadelphia. These events are symbolic in nature and generate a lot of income for the local economie, but what do we change? I feel the same about the State of Black America summit.
Who benefits besides Tavis Smiley and his sponsors. I give Tom Joyner a big pass because I appliaud his work. But this lip service game is tired and played out.

Sandra Mills at 12:59PM on Apr 7th 2008

11. First and foremost... Hillary and McCain were showing respect for MLK and the civil rights community. Just think of the howling if Hillary had not attended (probably another inferred "racist" sleight), and McCain's apology was sincere and needed. Yeah, it may be politics... but remember these people are running for President to represent all Americans, and their presence exemplified what kind of President she or he would be. Notably, Bush did not attend or even acknowledge the anniversary of MLK's assassination.

As a white voter, I cannot fathom the reason for Obama not attending, except for the reason given above in this article.

I long ago noticed that Obama chooses not to appear in significantly black events. I think his "white" campaign managers are steering him wrong. Skipping events like Memphis does not make him more appealing to whites, but rather makes him appear trying to avoid his ethnicity... which is ridiculous. It would be like Hillary trying to pretend she is not a woman... and notably Hillary does not shy away from women events and settings.

Bottom line... Obama is struggling with getting a large share of white voters. He is most likely the one who made the true overly political decision of choosing not to go to Memphis. It was a poor choice, especially when white voters overwhelmingly respect MLK... just look at McCain.

Nickberry at 1:17PM on Apr 7th 2008

12. Why am I NOT surprised!! Obama hasn’t backed up any of his speeches w/real action. He was the one who gave us “permission” to talk about race in America, yet he’s the ONLY candidate who was not in attendance at the event in Memphis?! I am African-American and I support HRC–I wish more from my community would think before voting. We have thrown 90% of our vote behind this man blindly. We haven’t thought about anything, we haven’t challenged Obama on anything, and we’ve pushed aside the fact that Obama has, time and time again, failed to make appearances at these important events for the Black community. He’s full of hot air, opportunistic, and should he become POTUS, black people will be extremely disappointed in what I predict will be his complete and utter neglect of our community. Obama has displayed a disturbing trend of talking the talk and forgetting to walk the walk–wake up Black America!!! It’s time to think critically and to stop doing everything in lock-step–it’s NOT helping our community one bit!!

Robyn Carr at 1:22PM on Apr 7th 2008

13. IF obama becomes president he will have no time to assist the frail black population instead he will be face with the dying economy and the war to fix which will take a few years for him to concentrate on the blacks if he gets a chance. So th e black people better chill out because you will be waiting for a very long time for obama to hear you cry again . Keep waiting for that day and it will never come

Banton at 1:23PM on Apr 7th 2008

14. We need to start holding him accountable--the fact that our community is attempting to justify these inactions by Obama and his campaign is ridiculous and short-sighted. Our vote has been taken for granted for years and years, so why are we continuing to allow this to happen now? Because we're dealing w/a black man? It's no different--black, brown, purple, or green--the black community needs to let ALL leaders know that they have a responsibility to our community. And that responsibility starts w/actually showing up to events such as these. A speech on race is great, but not after you've been boxed in politically to give it. Obama's campaign reeks of political opportunism, and we're letting him get away w/it--much to our detriment.

Robyn Carr at 1:41PM on Apr 7th 2008

15. We need to start holding him accountable--the fact that our community is attempting to justify these inactions by Obama and his campaign is ridiculous and short-sighted. Our vote has been taken for granted for years and years, so why are we continuing to allow this to happen now? Because we're dealing w/a black man? It's no different--black, brown, purple, or green--the black community needs to let ALL leaders know that they have a responsibility to our community. And that responsibility starts w/actually showing up to events such as these. A speech on race is great, but not after you've been boxed in politically to give it. Obama's campaign wreaks of political opportunism, and we're letting him get away w/it--much to our detriment.

Robyn Carr at 1:43PM on Apr 7th 2008

Next 15 Comments

Add your comments

Please keep your comments relevant to this blog entry: inappropriate or purely promotional comments may be removed. Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments. To create a live link, simply type the URL (including http://) or email address and we will make it a live link for you. You can put up to 3 URLs in your comments. Line breaks and paragraphs are automatically converted — no need to use <p> or <br> tags.

Your name (required):

Your email address (required, will not be shown to the public):

Your site’s URL (optional):

Do you want us to remember your personal information for next time?
   
Add your comments:

Comments

Most Recent Comments

(7 Days)
  • Hung Lo on Still Together: Oprah and Stedman Make Rare Appearance in New Jersey
  • warren on Fox Affiliate Tells Solange: "Quit Gravy-Training Off Your Sister"
  • Music Genie on Fox Affiliate Tells Solange: "Quit Gravy-Training Off Your Sister"
  • Kataushia on Obama-O'Riley Face Off Part 1 - Hypothetical Bombs Over Iran
  • Maya on Still Together: Oprah and Stedman Make Rare Appearance in New Jersey
  • Maya on Still Together: Oprah and Stedman Make Rare Appearance in New Jersey
  • FT on John McCain Now Wants Some Change, Too

Most Commented On

  • Marvelyn Brown: Young, Beautiful, and HIV Positive (984)
  • Clear View: Sherri Shepherd Isn't Going Anywhere (837)
  • YES - IT'S TRUE - BERNIE MAC IS DEAD (712)
  • Da Brat: Sentenced To Three Years In Prison (706)
  • Hi Family! Introducing My 'Partner' (343)
  • Elvis Mitchell Talks 'The Black List, Vol.1' (303)
  • Has King's Dream Been Fulfilled? (301)
  • Fox Affiliate Tells Solange: "Quit Gravy-Training Off Your Sister" (262)
  • Desperate Acts - Labeling Obama the Anti-Christ (249)
  • Cosby's Daughter Not Down With Real Black Folks (236)
  • New Meaning to Republican 'Family Values' (221)
  • 8 Million Might NOT Barack The Vote (217)

Also on AOL

More on Black Voices

  • African American Culture
  • Black College Sports
  • Black Entertainment
  • Black News
  • Black TV
  • Black Blogs
  • Black Movies
  • Black Music Month
  • Black Gossip
  • TV Blog

Hot Topics

  • Juanita Bynum
  • Barack Obama
  • Hurricane Katrina
  • OJ Simpson Arrest
  • Kimora Lee Simmons
  • Essence.com
  • Kwanzaa
  • Janet Jackson

More On AOL

  • Mail
  • Search
  • Movies
  • Spinner
  • Winamp
  • Shoutcast
  • MapQuest
  • CityGuide
  • Games
  • Music
  • TMZ
  • Television
  • Sports
  • Money
  • Engadget
  • Autoblog
  • Joystiq
  • BloggingStocks
  • TUAW
  • DownloadSquad
  • Styledash
  • Cinematical
  • TVSquad
  • RSS/Feeds

  • Terms Of Use
  • Updated Terms Of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Updated Privacy Policy
  • Trademarks
  • Site Map

AOL Black Voices, the premiere site for African-American culture and community, offers African-American message boards, profiles and chats, Africa-American sports, Africa-American news, African-American entertainment, African-American style and beauty, relationship advice and more. Share your voice at BV!

© 2008 AOL LLC. All Rights Reserved.

AOL@Black Voices © 2007 AOL LLC. All Rights Reserved.

BACK TO TOP
?